Jun 29, 2007

Sony Ericsson P1 review

The Sony Ericsson P1 is an exciting new smartphone that is to undoubtedly reign in the current Sony Ericsson portfolio. Powered by Symbian OS and featuring a QWERTY keyboard, a touchscreen TFT display with QVGA resolution and a 3.2 megapixel camera with auto focus, it represents the next level of the development of UIQ smartphones. As such, it seems that the Sony Ericsson P1 will be the flagship of Sony Ericsson smartphone line overrunning even the Sony Ericsson P990 and we were more than curious to find out how it performed in real life.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Sony Ericsson P1 official pictures

Key features:

  • Symbian 9.1 OS with UIQ 3 user interface
  • QWERTY keyboard
  • 2.6" 262K colors TFT touchscreen display
  • 3.2 megapixel camera with auto focus
  • Memory Stick Micro M2 memory card slot
  • UMTS, Wi-Fi, stereo Bluetooth, USB, Infrared
  • Secondary camera for video calls
  • Walkman-grade MP3 player and FM radio with RDS
  • Jog Dial navigation

Main disadvantages:

  • Awkward keyboard
  • No HSDPA support
  • No EDGE support

A P-series or a M-series one?

The Sony Ericsson P1 bears the design line of the already available Sony Ericsson M600. The same form factor but without a QWERTY keyboard was used in the music-oriented Sony Ericsson W950, too.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Sony Ericsson P1

Sony Ericsson M600 Sony Ericsson M600 Sony Ericsson M600 Sony Ericsson M600


Sony Ericsson M600

Naming the device P1 seems rather logical, since the next SE super smartphone should have come as P1000. But 1000 sounds really trite, so choosing the device model to be P1, is a good move. Rumors had it that the device would be called P700, and even our test handset reported being P700. We guess that the decision must have been taken in the last moment. The Sony Ericsson P1 seems more of an upgraded M600, but then again we suppose that the wide range of features it boasts motivated including it in the P-series. So the P1 would definitely be the flagship among Sony Ericsson smartphones, but hardware wise, it seems to be powered by the same 208 MHz processor as seen in M600, W950 and P990.

Sony Ericsson P800 Sony Ericsson P900 Sony Ericsson P910 Sony Ericsson P990


The P-series evolution

We were very excited when we got the opportunity to make a review of the eagerly awaited Sony Ericsson smartphone P1. It turned out though that the test handset is obviously a rather early prototype since we experienced frequent crashes in various situations and applications. Nevertheless, we have a great deal of confidence that these will be fixed in the final version.

The retail package will include a desk stand, a USB cable, a stereo headset, a protective pouch, a spare stylus, and a 512MB Memory Stick Micro M2 card. Of course, as with any other mobile phone, the contents of the retail package remain strictly market and country dependant.

Silver framed

The P1 smartphone measures 106 x 55 x 17 mm and weighs 124 g. The central place in the body is taken by the large 2.6" touchscreen TFT display. Above the display you can easily see the eye of the frontal VGA video call camera. Next to it, right in the dead center is the in-call speaker grill. Below it is the QWERTY keyboard that is almost a Sony Ericsson trademark - we haven't seen a similar design in the common mobile market. Three or four characters share each key and it depends on your pressing its left or right side or pressing it in a combination with the ALT key, that determines which character gets printed. A clever design, no doubt about it, but we would see if it's user-friendly enough to serve its purpose.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Video calls camera • Sony Ericsson P1 keyboard

The left side of the Sony Ericsson P1 features a hand strap eyelet, a Jog Dial and a hardware back key, which comes in handy when used in combination with the Jog Dial. The Jog Dial wheel itself is a three-way navigation solution - scroll up, scroll down and press to select or activate.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Left side view: strip eyelet, Jog Dial, Back key

The bottom side of the device is bare - it hosts only the usual Fast port and a microphone aperture.

Sony Ericsson P1


Bottom side view: Fast Port and microphone

The right side incorporates the camera shutter key, the Memory Stick Micro card slot and a shortcut key, which can be assigned several available applications. The default one is to start the Web browser.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Right side view: camera shutter key, memory card slot, personal shortcut key

The top side of the device features the Infrared port and the On/Off key.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Top side view: Infrared port and On/Off key

Just below the On/Off key is the slot for the stylus. It's more obvious when you take a look at the back of the handset.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Sony Ericsson P1 stylus

Speaking of the back, there is a certain thing down there that can really attract your attention. We are talking about the lens of the 3.2 megapixel camera which features autofocus and as you may have probably noticed, a dual LED flash. We saw that kind of flash used in Sony Ericsson K550. Obviously, Sony Ericsson are keeping the xenon flash for their high-end cameraphones only. Right above the camera lens is a silver line that in fact covers the loudspeaker.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Camera lens • loudspeaker cover

When you remove the battery cover, you will see the standard Sony Ericsson BST-33 950 mAh Li-Polymer battery that is rather frequently used by the manufacturer in a number of different handsets. According to official numbers, the battery should provide the P1 with enough power to keep it going for up to 350-440 hours of standby time or up to 5-10 hours of call time depending on whether you would use it in a UMTS network which takes its toll on battery life. Unfortunately, we could not test the phone's battery life since we used the phone heavily during our tests and thus the battery life we experienced was not indicative for the real-life performance of the handset. The SIM card slot of the P1 is not your regular Sony Ericsson one and the card itself slots into a place next to the camera lens.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Removing the battery cover and the battery

The Sony Ericsson P1 is nice to work with both your left and right hand. If you use the Jog Dial you would need the stylus rarely since it represents a rather adequate navigation solution. We enjoyed using the P1 and it surely feels nice when held in hand.

Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1 Sony Ericsson P1


Sony Ericsson P1 held in hand

Motorola RAZR maxx V6

Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Motorola keeps reusing its trustworthy old RAZR V3 design in almost all of its current models. Probably most of the users will agree that this is not a bad thing at all, as those are one of the finest, most beautiful phones on the market. RAZR maxx V6 is no exception to the rule.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Motorola RAZR maxx V6

Key features:

  • Large display
  • Touch sensitive buttons for music controls
  • HSDPA support (3.5G)
  • GPRS and EDGE, both Class 10
  • Bluetooth with A2DP profile (for stereo headset)
  • microSD card slot
  • 2 megapixel camera
  • Video calls camera
  • Pleasant light effects when the phone is ringing

Main disadvantages:

  • Touch sensitive keys are hard to use
  • No FM radio

Longer, thicker and heavier than the original V3 RAZR, the maxx V6 is a completely different story. It boasts HSDPA (3.5G), EDGE, stereo Bluetooth, 2 megapixel camera, memory card, a larger display and very modern design. So, the V3 just cannot compete. But there is another phone on the market which we can easily put next to the Motorola RAZR maxx V6 and that is Samsung Z560. Equipped with almost the same functions and extras, those two phones are major opponents.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Motorola RAZR maxx V6 and Samsung Z560

The typical slim-shell

With its dimensions of 104 x 53 x 15 mm and weight of 105 g, Motorola RAZR maxx V6 gets a place in the perfect middle of size and weight for a high-end clamshell phones. The Samsung Z560 is a bit smaller and weighs less but if we look at them in terms of design, the new Moto surely gets more applause. We can't practically think of any fault in the design of the phone.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Comparison between Motorola RAZR maxx V6 and Samsung Z560

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Motorola RAZR maxx V6 held in hand

As hard as it can be

The phone's plastic and metal construction is very nice and solid. It did not produce and creaks or plays and its clamshell closing mechanism works just perfect with a very recognizable sound when you close the flip. As in most of the cases with clamshell 3G phones, the video calls camera is in the middle of the construction and is visible only when the flip is open.

The top part of the closed phone has a great 65K colors display and above it is the 2 megapixel camera with two LED flash. Just beneath the display are the touch sensitive keys which serve as music control. There are the Play/Pause, Forward and Backward functions. Below them there is a Motorola logo and when the phone rings, the logo glows in blue accompanied by glowing blue lines on both sides of the display. Those light effects are really nice and add a nice feel to it.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


The front side

The back of the phone hosts the battery cover with a silver Motorola logo on it and the loudspeaker below it. Under the cover you may find the Motorola BZ60 Li-Ion battery with capacity of 940 mAh, which according to the manufacturer will last for 375 hours in stand-by mode and 3 hours of talk time. Regrettably, we can't comment on those figures as we used the phone heavily and the battery performance in normal every-day will prove different. Besides the battery, under the battery cover you will also see the memory card slot. It is hot-swappable but you have to remove the cover first. The SIM card bed is under the battery as you may have guessed.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Motorola V6 back panel • battery cover off • SIM card bed • battery

The left side of the clamshell has dual volume key on it and a button which opens a simple menu on the external display which controls some basic functions. A USB port is located on the left side. It is the usual miniUSB port that Motorola puts in almost all of its models.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Left side of the phone

The right side features a camera release button and an eyelet for a wrist strap. The top and bottom sides of the body are bare.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Right side of the phone

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


Top and bottom sides

When opened, the phone reveals its fantastic 2.2" 256K colors TFT display with resolution of 240 x 320 pixels. Above it are the speaker grills and a Motorola logo. The other part of the open phone consists of the keypad. Between the two parts, in the joint, is the VGA video calls camera.

Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6 Motorola RAZR maxx V6


The phone open • speaker grills and logo • VGA video calls camera